Thanks Wanda. As you say, the review contains spoilers and seems to reveal a significant part of the ending, so I've put the text in a spoiler tag below. For those who don't want to read it all, here is some basic info about Simon's role:
He plays Guy, a very rich and successful client of Nat (Rose Byrne). Nat, newly married to Josh (Rafe Spall) begins to fall for Guy who is a far cry from the struggling writer of a husband she has become resentful of.
I Give it a Year Review By Kayla Ferguson
Marriage these days is fleeting, unpredictable and hardly sacred like it used to be. So why not make a crude, quasi-romantic movie about it?
I Give it a Year, directed by Dan Mazer and slated to hit theaters February 8, 2013, is a laugh-out-loud romantic comedy that downplays and makes humorous everything that is awful about marriage. It’s no secret that marriage isn’t all it’s cracked up to be and this film ensures that everyone watching understands that, making all the single people out there slightly less anxious about their supposed relationship ineptitude and all the married people a little bit uncomfortable at the thought of their daily annoyances related to their spouse.
Nat (Rose Byrne) and Josh (Rafe Spall) alongside Chloe (Annie Faris) and Guy (Simon Baker) are able to perfectly depict how sometimes the idea of the perfect person doesn’t necessarily equate to the perfect relationship. Of course the cliché sappy love story still exists—that’s why Nat and Josh get married in the first place. But nine short months after their wedding that all their friends secretly thought was a bad idea in the first place, they are far from the perpetually misunderstood blissful honeymoon of the first year of marriage.
It’s hardly surprising when Nat begins to fall for Guy, a very rich and successful client of hers. He is a far cry from the struggling writer of a husband she has become resentful of and the sparks that fly between them are more obvious than fireworks on the fourth of July. Simultaneously Josh begins to realize that maybe he shouldn’t have broken up with his ex-girlfriend Chloe afterall. Of course, neither one wants to be the one to give up on a marriage and they agree to fight for something that both wished would have ended months ago.
Although the general storyline may sound slightly dramatic, it’s not. Nearly every scene offers absurd, relatable and sometime jaw-dropping comedy that makes every audience member root for their breakup, not out of contempt of the characters but out of a genuine understanding that bad relationships suck. Of course, the hopes of the audience comes true at the end, when Josh politely asks Nat to divorce him and she says yes, telling him he has made her “the happiest girl in the world.” It’s funny, in an unpredictably predictable way.
Comic in it’s absurdity, I Give it a Year politely (read “humorously) suggests that maybe marriage isn’t everything the world always thinks it’s going to be—and there is nothing wrong with that. One can only imagine that quite a few people left the theater reevaluating their relationship and maybe secretly wishing they could be Nat or Josh for a day, or maybe a lifetime.
But don’t be fooled into thinking this movie stops at the respectable line of intelligent comedy. A movie of this type could not be made humorous without ample crude humor—the signature “penis shot” that has become somewhat of an expectation in R-rated comedies these days as well as ample profanity and politically incorrect jokes told by “that white guy” target the movie towards a niche market. And it’s probably not the fifty-year married couple that would watch the screen in angst at everything they didn’t do to change their marriage when they were younger but instead liberal 20-somethings that can authentically appreciate the idea of divorce. If this sounds like you, than what better movie to check out for Valentine’s Day 2013?
Date: Thursday, 01-Nov-12, 11:29 AM | Message # 108
Fair Dinkum
Messages: 4127
Status: Offline
Ilan Eshkeri to Score ‘I Give It a Year’ Excerpt: Ilan Eshkeri has signed on to score the upcoming romantic comedy I Give It a Year. Eshkeri has previously scored last year’s comedy Johnny English Reborn for Working Title. His other credits include Matthew Vaughn’s Stardust and Layer Cake, as well as Ralph Fiennes’ Coriolanus. Eshkeri’s other upcoming projects include Ralph Fiennes’ The Other Woman, the romantic comedy Austenland starring Keri Russell and the animated feature Justin and the Knights of Valour. http://filmmusicreporter.com/2012....-a-year
Why oh why can't we have a comedy without the four letter words and the full frontal nudity. I can't be the only one who yearns for old fashioned type of entertainment. Can I? I don't think I'm a prude but perhaps on reflection I am. Oh well. Something else for me not to see, and I was so looking forward to this film.
I remember Simon trying on new glasses in March this year and we saw him with different glasses in three pictures (they are in the archive O&A here). They look quite similar. Maybe he did this to choose the glasses he would accept to wear for the filming?
Why oh why can't we have a comedy without the four letter words and the full frontal nudity. I can't be the only one who yearns for old fashioned type of entertainment. Can I? I don't think I'm a prude but perhaps on reflection I am. Oh well. Something else for me not to see, and I was so looking forward to this film. sad
I totally agree with you. I'm really not even much of a prude. I just don't find these kinds of crude things funny or charming. So I won't be seeing this film. Hope it does well for Simon's sake but I'll be saving my money (which I need to do anyway).
When I first heard about Simon’s involvement in this Dan Mazer project, I didn’t feel at all optimistic about it, mainly because Sacha Baron Cohen's humour is not my type of thing. Then I thought about some of Working Title’s other projects and also I read some hopeful-sounding comments, and that made me feel much more enthusiastic about it. But the "wineandcheesecrowd" reviewer’s comments about crude humour and the movie being targeted at a niche 20-something market, have plummeted my expectations to rock bottom. Having said that, I always like to judge things for myself, and it would take a lot more than a bit of crass humour to stop me going to see Simon on the big screen (at least twice I should imagine )
Quote (Sun)
I remember Simon trying on new glasses in March this year and we saw him with different glasses in three pictures (they are in the archive O&A here). They look quite similar.
I think you're right, they were very similar. There were the pics of him trying glasses on, and then there was also a photo of him carrying a gas canister.
I figure I can enjoy crude as well as the next person, as long as there is some intelligence behind it. And since Simon is involved, I do expect some intelligence. I also think that he and Rose Byrne will be bringing some class to the movie.
P.S. I love the glasses he's wearing in the photo.
Message edited by Wand6122360 - Monday, 12-Nov-12, 2:42 AM
Thanks Fran and Wanda! I thought I was the only one who is looking forward seeing Simon on the big screen for the first time! As for the 'crude', I would prefer if this had to do with the other guy - Rafe Spall - not Simon! One thing that worries me, though, is whether I, a fifty-something, will look funny amongst all the twenty-somethings!!!
Thanks for the scan. Love the pics! Like the glasses better than Simon's black frame. But well, I like him best without glasses but I understand that he doesn't like contact lenses, I couldn't wear them too. Can't wait to see the movie. I hope it comes to the cinema next year in Germany too. I even go to the movies for him, haven't done that in a long time. I always wait for the movies I want to see til they are on DVD or pay tv.
@lenacr.....think of it this way....there will be cinemas all over the world full of twenty-somethings.....and in each one....there will be one of us, drinking coke and eating popcorn, and watching Simon....all together and apart....don't feel out of place...it will be dark...no one will see!